Savita in Catholic IrelandPosted on the 18 November 2012 by Nelton @neltondsouza
Much has been said regarding Savita Halappanavar's case in Ireland. Before any more is said I feel I need to express myself not to present a defence for anyone but to just throw some light on a few things.
The Republic of Ireland is a sovereign country. Yes, it's made up of more than 80% Catholics but in no way it means that Catholic laws are enforced like in some Islamic nations in the Middle East where Islamic laws are enforced whether you like it or not. If Ireland is deemed as a Catholic country then we can comfortably say that we live in a Hindu Rashtra as the same case applies here too.
Secondly, we aren’t the right people to discuss this subject as we don’t know the true facts and the entire story. All we know is what’s been fed to us by the media which has left no stone unturned to give it maximum coverage. Thanks to having 2 sensitive issues rolled in 1 – a feminine side and a religious side, enough to get people ranting. Trust me if Bal Thackeray hadn’t passed away you would have seen a lot more of this. Discussing this subject without all the necessary facts and figures is like reacting to Ashwathama’s death in the Mahabharata. No one even bothered to find out whether the elephant was killed or the son.
Savita had been living and practicing dentistry in Ireland for quite some time. I wonder all this while esp. when she was expecting she didn’t get versed with the laws prevalent in the country. It’s important to know for any person to know the laws and workings of the land esp. when you are not in your home country. Her defence saying that she is a Hindu and hence the so called Catholic laws shouldn’t be applied to her is like saying that I’m not a Shiv Sainik hence all shops and public transport should be open for me even though all have been forcibly closed down on account of Bal Thackeray death.
The doctors and the hospital in this case were under a tight situation where the only options were to choose between the deep sea and the devil. In either case they would be criticized and are to this day. This reminds me of situations in India where the doctor refuses to act because it’s a police case.
This case is a very complicated one with many angles and perceptions. Any action now cannot bring Savita back and lessen the pain of the bereaved family. What can and should be done is make the laws clear and humane. If that’s achieved we need not worry about saving another Savita, she would be in safe hands.
These articles might interest you :
Flying nun or Satanic Chucky doll? Today I had been going to blog about the second day of the Guardian’s excellent weekend seminar on Self Publishing. Read moreBy Thejohnfleming
Members of anti-abortion groups demonstrating in Dublin last yearThe headlines were slightly misleading, to say the least. “Ireland to legalise abortion” was... Read moreBy Therealsupermum
DEBATE, FAMILY, PARENTING, SELF EXPRESSION, SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES
The report out to-day opens up the abuse by the Catholic Church and by Nuns of young girls and woman. Thousands of women and young girls sent to Catholic-run... Read moreBy Harry
DEBATE, HUMOR, SELF EXPRESSION
My friend Meagen is pretty amazing. Not only is she the mom of two adorable boys the exact same age as my girls, she also runs her own consulting firm... Read moreBy Mamamelch
DIARIES, SELF EXPRESSION
****"Waiting on Wednesday" is a weekly event hosted by Jill at the Breaking The Spine, that spotlights upcoming releases that we're eagerly anticipating. Read moreBy Literaryexploration
Lennox…#HowlingforLennox “A Belfast woman has failed in a final attempt to spare the life of her pit bull terrier-type dog.”... Read moreBy Ciciwriter
Queen Elizabeth II shakes hands with Northern Ireland’s deputy minister and former IRA deputy leader Martin McGuinness, the Sinn Fein activist who probably... Read moreBy Solarisastro
MOST POPULAR FROM SELF EXPRESSION
- Stationery - the written word. by Ashleylister
- Dog Days of Summer by Bigcitylittleblog
- Father's Day Gift Guide - How to nail it (you're welcome) by Parentalparody
- 5 Reasons Not To Compare Yourself to Others by Stephsscribe